Scratch And Dent Sword Mystery Deal – Sold As Is, Random Sword, Gently Used

I have ordered 4 swords from this and each one is better then the last I tell all my friends about it I am highly satisfied

Received a short sword version of anduil flame of the west from LOTR and a Shinwa display sword would recommend!

I got a very red katana not great quality but I wasn't looking for wonderful quality here. Diffidently worth buying.

I ordered 2, I like what I got, which was a Shinwa display sword set with stand and a cain sword.

I love the random picks that I get. I have been pleasantly surprised. I got a Shinwa short sword. I think it’s a beautiful! Thanks guys!!

Once again, I ordered 2 swords and received 2 swords. One was fully functional and the other was a quality display sword. I was happy with both. I will be ordering again.

I ordered two swords and received a single sword and a two-sword set so I feel I came out way ahead on this deal. Since receiving this item, I have ordered two more that haven't arrived yet.

I have to say that like most people that try their luck with these items, my results were mixed. My first time I went with 2 swords and 3 knives. I got 2 out of 5. My second time...4 out of 4. Good blades that I liked or were useful to me. Still undecided if there will be a third time.

Bought two of these after reading the reviews. I was pretty excited to get them hoping I'd get lucky and get something cool. One "sword" was a tanto, cheap stainless steel and cheap wood scabbard, fit and finish was pretty good though. Second sword was actually the length of a sword, again cheap Chinese stainless, rat tang with screw-on handle hardware, flat edge with rounded tip. Overall I was disappointed but I believe that was my fault, hoping for something cool, or even two actual sword products. Still not a terrible deal I guess

I received the hand forged 1060 carbon steel samurai sword Wich had some minnor scratches but nothing major and is $125 on budk this company has yet to fail me and I plan on ordering other scratch and dent sale items

This is the first time I have bought the Scratch and Dent so I got 2 of them. First one I opened was the BLACK GANKYIL KATANA w/ stand a $50 katana with no apparent damage AND the second is the TITAN ATTACK FANTASY SWORD with minor damage to the tip which I can deal with considering its an Attack On Titan SWORD being sold at $86. A total value of $136 for only $50!! Thanks BUDK I'll be buying more soon

Recieved little better than a "Blank". Oxidation on the blade, mold on the sheath, the handle is loosely wrapped with what essentially amounts to waxed shoelace. No guard, and not even an attempt at polishing the steel around the lanyard tail. I essentially bought a large drop point (about the size of a Spatha) that will take a good deal of work to make it even moderately aesthetically desirable. The one pro is this is obviously high-carbon and full-tang, but I won't be buying another "as is sword".

Bought the machete and fixed blade scratch and dents and got some decent value from them nothing major just like $10 more then what I paid but for this one I ordered one and ended up getting a worse deal then had I just bought the sword outright. Spent $24 to get sent a sword they're selling for $19. These shouldn't even be in this especially if only one is purchased

I paid 40$ for 2 swords. The package made it here in less than a week and the first sword I unboxed was a Honshu midnight forge katana which I have been eyeing for a while now. The second katana seems very well made tho not sure of the brand. Will be getting this again for sure!! Thanks BudK

Worth every penny and more!! The package arrived in under a week and out of the two I ordered 1 was a Honshu midnight forge katana. Will be ordering this again very soon. Thanks BudK!

I did not get a lucky draw. Got a red Black Legion Ninja Sword and a 17in hacker machete thing. Good quality on that one. 20 bucks each on with a blind pick is still worth the gamble. Maybe I will try one more time. Delivered quick and always good customer service.

I did not get a lucky draw. Got a black legion ninja sword and a weird 17 inch hacker machete thing. Good quality on that one actually. 20 bucks each was still a good deal. Delivered quick and always good customer service.

Ordered this hoping to get something I could clean up at home as a project. Ended up with a sword that was on sale for less than what I paid for here, probably because the MSRP was $24.99. It's a mystery box from the send back pile, don't get your hopes up!

I ordered two scratch and dent swords. One was a Red Dragon Katana with no scratches or dents that I could find. Gave it to my son to practice iaido with. The second was a (no lie) Sokojikawa Chinese Dragon Tanto!!! No scratches or dents- the hinge on the storage box wouldn't latch properly!!!

Neither are real sword just play ones one wasn't even a sword just a cane with blunt sides and end. Can't even find them on here. But you are getting basically what ever they can't sell or are returned. These were probably very old stock as they are no longer on their site.

I received a Forged Warrior jungle beast like another recent reviewer did. Other than some rust on the tip, it looks great, and I can deal with the rust. It is not at all sharp, however, and I will also need to deal with that. I would likely be more bothered by the dullness of the blade had I paid full price. It is not a sword I probably would have bought otherwise, but I think it will be a nice addition to my collection once it is cleaned and sharpened. The other sword I received is the El Diablo Sword and Kunai set, which currently sells on this site for $19.98. It appears to have some blemishes on the sword (a few scratches, but nothing bad). Neither the sword or the Kunais are sharp, and they are very light and feel cheap. Had I paid the $25 for this set, I would have been quite unhappy. But since I ordered two scratch and dent swords, I paid $20, the same price for which it is selling. I would have never bought this set, and I am probably going to give it away or use it for a Halloween prop. The verdict: the Jungle Beast is a nice piece for $20 (it sells here for $70 retail); The Diablo set is not. The anticipation is fun, and I might order a couple more and see what I get. At the least, I can use the swords for Halloween props, much like I do with some other cheap swords I own.

not what I was expecting or hoping for, it was four cheap swords unscratched or dented I never would have bought, though the forged warrior jungle beast is pretty cool and kept me somewhat content. The only actual blemished blade was a worthless piece of ugly wall art. the cheap blades all made cool gifts though, and the waiting was a blast. I will probably focus on BOGO in the future, or just cheap full tang blades. I ordered 5, they could have given me one nice one.

I get how it works, but I ordered 3 of this and got 3 of the exact same sword. Could have atleast reached into a different bin for one of them. Quality was good otherwise.

Bought one for $24 and I got an item that they sell for $19. I paid $5 more then I should have and not to mention the item was bogo so I would have gotten two. Instead I feel ripped off, shouldn't have items that you're selling for less on this one.